Flour, water, and patience. That's all you need.
Days 4-5 — The Quiet Period
This is where people give up. Don't. After the false rise, your starter may go completely flat. No bubbles. No rise. Possibly hooch on top. This is the valley between the bacterial bloom dying off and the real wild yeast taking hold. Keep feeding. Trust the process.
I'm on Day 4 and nothing is happening. Should I start over?
No. Days 4-5 are the quiet period where the initial bacterial bloom dies off and wild yeast is colonizing. This is the most common point where people quit. Keep feeding. It will come back to life. Most starters need 7-14 days.
My starter rose on Day 2 or 3. Is it ready to bake with?
Almost certainly not. That early rise is caused by leuconostoc bacteria, not wild yeast. It looks exciting but it's a false signal. Those bacteria die off as the pH drops and your starter will go flat for a day or two before the real yeast takes over. Keep feeding.
What's that dark liquid on top of my starter?
That's hooch, alcohol produced when your starter is hungry. It just means it needs a feeding. Pour it off for a milder flavor or stir it in for more sourness. Either way it's not harmful.
Can I use all-purpose flour instead of whole wheat on Day 1?
Yes, but it may take a few extra days. Whole wheat and rye flours carry more wild yeast and bacteria on the bran and germ, giving you a head start. If all-purpose is all you have, use it. It will still work.
Do I have to discard every day? It feels so wasteful.
You do need to discard or use a portion before each feeding. Without it you'd need exponentially more flour each day and the starter's pH can't develop properly. Save the discard in a jar in the fridge. After Day 5 you can use it for pancakes, waffles, crackers, and flatbread.
Does the type of water matter?
Heavily chlorinated tap water can slow fermentation. Let tap water sit uncovered for an hour to off-gas chlorine, or use filtered water. Avoid distilled water which has no minerals. Most tap water works fine.
My kitchen is cold (below 70°F). What should I do?
Cold slows fermentation. Try the oven-light trick: place the jar in your oven with only the light on, not the heat. The bulb warms the oven to roughly 75-80°F. A bread proofer like the Brød & Taylor Folding Proofer is the premium solution.
My starter smells terrible. Like paint thinner or old cheese.
That's normal during the first week. The aggressive smell comes from acetic acid bacteria and acetone production. As the wild yeast population strengthens the aroma will shift to pleasant, tangy, and mildly yeasty. If you see pink, orange, or fuzzy mold that's contamination. Toss it and start over with a clean jar.
What's the difference between active starter and sourdough discard?
Active sourdough starter is freshly fed and at its peak rise: doubled, bubbly, domed. It has maximum leavening power. Sourdough discard is unfed starter with little to no leavening power, but it adds sourdough flavor to recipes that use other leavening like baking soda, baking powder, or instant yeast.
How do I know if my starter is dead vs. just sluggish?
If it smells sour, even if it's not rising much, it's not dead. Keep feeding. If it develops visible mold, fuzzy spots or pink and orange streaks, discard it and start fresh. A sluggish starter usually just needs warmer temperatures, more consistent feedings, or a boost from whole grain flour.
Can I buy a starter instead of making one?
Absolutely. The SourHouse Goldie starter kit gives you a healthy mature dehydrated starter that's ready to activate in 2-3 days instead of waiting 7-14. It's a great option if you want to skip the creation process and get straight to baking.
I want to use rye flour for my feedings. Is that okay?
Yes. Rye is excellent for starters because it ferments vigorously. Many experienced bakers feed with a mix of 70% all-purpose and 30% rye. A 100% rye starter will ferment faster and be more acidic so you'll need more frequent feedings.