Crust & Crumb Academy
Crust & Crumb Academy · Sourdough
Overnight Sourdough English Muffins
Crust & Crumb Academy Seal
Prep Time
20 minutes
🕐
Total Time
10-14 hours
💧
Hydration
62%
🍞
Yield
10-12 English muffins
🌡
Bake Temp
300°F

Better than Thomas' with ingredients you can actually pronounce.

Ingredients

GramsVolumeIngredientBaker's %
Dough
400g3¼ cupsBread flour
100g½ cupActive {{sourdough starter}}
200g¾ cup + 2 tbspWhole milk
50g3½ tbspWater
30g2 tbspUnsalted butter
20g1 tbspHoney
8g1½ tspFine sea salt
For Shaping & Cooking
as needed~½ cupCornmeal or semolina
as needed1-2 tbspClarified butter or oil

Process

1
Feed your starter
If refrigerated, discard all but 30g and feed with 60g flour + 60g water. Let it sit at room temperature until doubled and bubbly, usually 4-8 hours depending on your kitchen temp.
2
The Float test
Drop a small spoonful of starter into a glass of water. If it floats, you're ready to go. If it sinks, give it more time.
3
Warm the liquids
In a small bowl or measuring cup, combine the milk, water, and melted butter. Temperature should be 80-90°F (warm to the touch but not hot).
4
Combine wet ingredients
In a large bowl, add your active sourdough starter and honey. Pour in the warm milk mixture and whisk until the starter is dispersed.
5
Add the flour
Add the bread flour and stir with a wooden spoon or dough whisk until you have a shaggy, sticky mass. Don't worry about perfection here.
6
Rest (Fermentolyse)
Cover the bowl and let it sit for 30 minutes. This rest period allows the flour to hydrate and gluten development to begin naturally.
7
Add salt and mix
Sprinkle the salt over the dough. Using your hand (wet it first), dimple the salt into the dough, then squeeze and fold the dough on itself to incorporate. Continue mixing by hand or with a stand mixer fitted with a dough hook for 5-6 minutes until the dough is smooth, slightly tacky, and pulls away from the sides of the bowl.
8
Windowpane test
The dough should stretch into a thin membrane without tearing. If it tears easily, mix for another 2 minutes.
9
Shape into ball
Perform one set of stretch and folds in the bowl, then shape the dough into a rough ball.
10
Cover and rest
Cover the bowl tightly with plastic wrap or a damp towel.
11
Ferment overnight
Leave at room temperature (65-72°F) for 8-12 hours. In a warm kitchen, lean toward 8 hours. In a cool kitchen, closer to 12.
12
What to look for
In the morning, the dough should be noticeably larger (not necessarily doubled), domed on top, and jiggly when you shake the bowl. You should see bubbles on the surface and around the edges.
13
Prepare your surface
Generously dust your work surface with flour. Prepare a parchment-lined baking sheet and dust it liberally with cornmeal or semolina.
14
Turn out the dough
Gently tip the dough onto the floured surface. Handle it like a newborn—minimal force.
15
Pat to thickness
Using floured hands, gently pat (don't roll!) the dough to about ¾-inch thickness. If it springs back aggressively, let it rest 5 minutes and try again.
16
Cut the muffins
Dip your 3-inch biscuit cutter in flour between each cut to prevent sticking. Press straight down—don't twist. Cutting creates clean edges that help the muffins rise evenly.
17
Transfer to sheet
Place each cut muffin on the prepared baking sheet, leaving 2 inches between them. Flip each one so both sides are coated in cornmeal.
18
Gather and re-cut scraps
Gently gather the scraps, press together (don't kneading|knead), pat out, and cut more muffins. These 're-roll' muffins won't be quite as tender but still taste great.
19
Cover loosely
Drape the baking sheet with a clean kitchen towel or plastic wrap.
20
Rest at room temperature
Let the muffins rise for 45-60 minutes. They should puff up and look soft and pillowy.
21
Poke test
Gently poke a muffin with a floured finger. The indent should slowly fill back about halfway. If it springs back immediately, give them more time. If it doesn't spring back at all, they may be slightly overproofed (still edible, just denser).
22
Preheat your griddle
Heat a cast iron skillet or griddle over medium-low heat (275-300°F if you have a thermometer). Preheat for at least 10 minutes for even heat distribution.
23
Grease lightly
Brush with a thin layer of clarified butter or neutral oil. You need very little.
24
Add the muffins
Carefully transfer 3-4 muffins to the griddle, leaving space between them. Don't overcrowd.
25
Cover and cook
Place a lid or inverted baking sheet over the muffins. Cook for 7-10 minutes until the bottom is deep golden brown.
26
Flip carefully
Using a spatula, gently flip each muffin. The cooked side should be golden brown with some darker spots.
27
Cook the second side
Cover again and cook for another 7-10 minutes. Check by pressing gently on the side—it should feel firm, not squishy.
28
Check internal temp
For precision, use an instant-read thermometer. Internal temperature should reach 200-205°F in the center.
29
Cool on a rack
Transfer cooked muffins to a wire rack. Repeat with remaining muffins.
30
Let them cool slightly
Wait at least 5 minutes. Too hot and they'll steam and become gummy when you split them.
31
Fork-split technique
Insert a fork into the side of the muffin, about halfway through. Work your way around the entire circumference, poking holes every quarter inch.
32
Pull apart
Once you've gone all the way around, gently pry the two halves apart with the fork or your fingers.
33
Toast if desired
Pop the halves in a toaster until golden and crispy on the cut surface.
34
Load up with toppings
Butter, jam, honey, cream cheese, eggs benedict, breakfast sandwiches—the world is your oyster.
35
Pat dough to ¾-inch thickness
Use floured hands, don't roll with a pin.
36
Cut with 3-inch round cutter
Dip cutter in flour between cuts.
37
Transfer to cornmeal-dusted sheet
Flip to coat both sides.
38
Let rise 45-60 minutes
Before cooking on griddle.
39
Divide dough
Into 10-12 equal portions (~75g each).
40
Roll each into a ball
Then flatten to ¾-inch thick disc.
41
Roll edges in cornmeal
Coat all sides.
42
Place on prepared sheet
Let rise and cook as usual.
43
Pat dough into rectangle
10x12 inch rectangle.
44
Use Bench scraper
To cut into 12 equal squares.
45
Coat all sides in cornmeal
For classic texture.
46
Let rise and cook as usual
Square muffins toast beautifully.
47
Preheat cast iron
Over medium-low for 10 minutes.
48
Brush lightly
With clarified butter or oil.
49
Cook muffins 7-10 minutes per side
Covered for even cooking.
50
Check internal temp
Reaches 200-205°F.
51
Preheat griddle with lid
For even heat.
52
Lightly grease surface
Thin layer of butter or oil.
53
Cook muffins 7-10 minutes per side
Covered for steam.
54
Temperature control is automatic
Great for beginners.
55
Cook on griddle 5-6 minutes per side
Until golden.
56
Transfer to baking sheet
For oven finishing.
57
Bake at 350°F for 5-8 minutes
Until internal temp reaches 200°F.
58
Great for large batches
Finish multiple muffins at once.

Baker's Percentages

Bread flour
100%
Active Sourdough starter
25%
Whole milk
50%
Water
12%
Unsalted butter
8%
Honey
5%
📐 Learn How Baker's % Works →
Henry's Tip

No starter? Use the yeasted variation in the notes section. Same great muffins, different timeline.

Classroom Lessons

Check out the Goldie and DoughBed from SourHouse - Use code HBK23